16-Year-Old Michael Garner Performs Cody Johnson’s “’Til You Can’t” As ‘American Idol’ Journey Comes To An End

Last Monday night, viewers saw Michael Garner get one step closer to becoming the next American Idol when he won the sing-off against fellow contestant Jayson Garner. This simple yet impactful performance earned the 16-year-old a spot in the Top 30. Tonight, he brought the energy up on stage in Hawaii with a Cody Johnson hit.

The stakes were especially high this week, with both the looming Top 20 cut and the return of the platinum tickets. Nerves were clearly written on Garner’s face as he spoke to the camera before his performance, knowing that he had the eyes of the judges, his fellow contestants and a group of industry experts on him this week.

“Definitely got to bring my A-game. I got to do something,” he noted.

Garner chose to turn things up a notch by performing Cody Johnson’s award-winning song, “’Til You Can’t.” Known for its powerful storytelling and demanding vocal range, it’s safe to assume that this is not an easy track to tackle, but the high school student from Forrest City, AR rose to the challenge. He poured emotion into every lyric and even attempted to hit the high notes, proving that his talent and dedication is well beyond his years.

Feedback from the judging panel was not shown this time around, but a few members of the carefully selected group of Industry executive did give their thoughts.

Up first was Dancing with the Stars pro and choreographer, Sasha Farber, who honestly shared that he wasn’t as impressed by Michael Garner’s delivery as he was hoping to be.

“It felt like something was a little off. Maybe it wasn’t his best performance.”

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by American Idol (@americanidol)

Rolling Stones co-editor-in-chief, Shirley Halperin, then jokingly described him as being a country version of Justin Bieber.

Unfortunately, as the Top 20 spots were announced one by one, Michael Garner’s name was not called, marking the end of his journey on the show.

Those who did make the cut will perform on a new stage next week at Aulani, A Disney resort and Spa. Over the next two weeks, contestants will sing for the chance to earn American’s votes. Along the way, they will receive advice and guidance from new mentors, Brad Paisley and Keke Palmer.

New episodes of American Idol air Monday nights at 8:00 p.m. ET/PT on ABC and on streaming the following day on Hulu.