WATCH: John Foster Turns Luke Bryan’s ‘No’ To A ‘Yes’ With A Cover Of Conway Twitty’s ‘Goodbye Time’ On ‘American Idol’

“I don’t know if vocally it’s there to make it through many rounds of American Idol, but I think you got a nice voice…”

By

Madeleine O’Connell

| Posted on

March 24, 2025

at

1:51 pm

Share on:

John Foster, Luke Bryan; Photos Courtesy ABC, American Idol

John Foster is a medical student with a deep love for traditional country music and a dream of sharing his passion with the world through American Idol. Before putting his vocals on display, he buttered up the judges with some authentic Louisiana food in personalized coolers as a way to showcase his Cajun hospitality.

As Luke Bryan got to tasting the treats, Foster explained that he is studying biology right now and on a pre-med track to go to medical school.

“I have a passion for cancer treatment,” he said before adding, “The dream is to be a singing oncologist.”

John Foster; Photo by Disney/Eric McCandless
John Foster; Photo by Disney/Eric McCandless

Foster presents himself with true southern charm and an intelligence that will, hopefully, have a major impact on the world of medicine one day. But during his audition, the Idol judges were more focused on his vocal skills that are reminiscent of timeless country acts like Alan Jackson and Conway Twitty.

While donning jeans, a flannel and a cowboy hat, Foster began strumming his guitar to Jackson’s iconic tune, “Don’t Rock The Jukebox.” The judges sat quietly as they admired the traditional and authentic twangy sound radiating throughout his vocals. This acoustic performance found Carrie Underwood reminiscing over her first concert, when she saw Alan Jackson perform in 1994.

“I was 11. Love me some Alan,” the country star gushed.

John Foster; Photo by Disney/Eric McCandless
John Foster; Photo by Disney/Eric McCandless

She then asked Foster if he had another song he could sing that would show a bit more of his vocal range. He opted for another classic country song – Conway Twitty’s “Goodbye Time.”

Before he could even get the first lyric out, Luke Bryan gave an excited “oh hell” as he admitting, “I was singing it all day.”

The country star couldn’t help but jump in on a few lyrics and also offer words of encouragement as Foster confidently let his musical ability shine in front of the judges.

The power behind his vocals slowly increased as Bryan stood up and delivered the final lyrics alongside the hopeful contestant.

“If being free is worth what you leave behind/ And if it’s too late for love to change your mind/ Then it’s goodbye time,” Foster sang, earning a round of applause and a “thank you” from the judges.

YouTube video

Underwood was impressed by his second song choice and explained that she “got the information that I wanted out of that. There’s such a sweet spot in your voice that that song really brought out.”

She also offered him a bit of advice on how to succeed if he were to move forward in the competition.

“If you end up going through to Hollywood, when we ask you to sing different genres, be yourself for sure, but definitely think about how you’re going to navigate different situations,” she told him.

Lionel Richie agreed with his fellow judge, stating that he would like to hear more individuality from Foster in the future.

“I mean, I love the timber, but you’re going to carve your way out now and start making your sound.”

Bryan admitted he was initially leaning towards giving Foster a “no” but his second delivery ended up winning him over.

“Lionel said what my heart was thinking,’ he shared honestly. “I don’t know if vocally it’s there to make it through many rounds of American Idol, but I think you got a nice voice. You’ve got a lot of great tools. That last song certainly showed us that. I’m a Yes.”

With two more nods of approval from Richie and Underwood, John Foster was officially given the golden ticket to move onto Hollywood week.

Foster was one of many artists that won over the judges during the latest round of American Idol auditions that aired on Sunday, March 23. Viewers can check back in to see the final round of auditions on Sunday, March 30 when the show airs at 8 p.m. ET on ABC. Episodes are also available to stream on Hulu the following day.

Share on:

Madeleine O’Connell graduated from North Central College with a bachelors degree in Journalism and Broadcast Communications before deciding to pursue her studies further at DePaul University. There, she earned her masters degree in Digital Communication & Media Arts. O’Connell served as a freelance writer for over two years while also interning with the Academy of Country Music, SiriusXM and Circle Media and assisting with Amazon Music’s Country Heat Weekly podcast. In addition to Country Now, she has been published in American Songwriter, Music Mayhem, and Holler.Country. Madeleine O’Connell is a member of the Country Music Association and the Academy of Country Music.