Carrie Underwood Recreates Her ‘American Idol’ Audition in Full-Circle Moment as a Judge

Watch as she reprises her performance of “I Can’t Make You Love Me.”

By

Lauren Jo Black

| Posted on

March 17, 2025

at

2:32 pm

Share on:

Carrie Underwood; Photos Courtesy American Idol, YouTube

In 2004, Carrie Underwood took a leap of faith when she auditioned for the fourth season of American Idol. Her standout cover of Bonnie Raitt’s “I Can’t Make You Love Me” earned her a ticket to Hollywood and ultimately, she would go on to win the competition

Carrie Underwood, American Idol Audition; Photo via YouTube
Carrie Underwood, American Idol Audition; Photo via YouTube

Over two decades later, Underwood has returned to the show as a judge, marking a full-circle moment in her life and career. During Sunday’s American Idol episode, the country superstar “auditioned” for the show once again, delivering an incredible acapella performance of “I Can’t Make You Love Me” from the judges panel while seated between Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan. 

Carrie Underwood; Photo Courtesy American Idol
Carrie Underwood; Photo Courtesy American Idol

Underwood’s vocals sounded as incredible as ever as she sang the iconic hit. Richie even joked, “you’re going to Hollywood!”   

The video of her performance included clips form her original audition, once again bringing things full-circle for the eight-time GRAMMY winner. 

Reflecting on her American Idol journey, Underwood recalled the moment she received her ticket to Hollywood and how it deepened her connection with the contestants. Having experienced that life-changing moment herself, she now relates to the hopefuls on a more personal level.  

YouTube video

“I definitely see bits of myself in these different hopefuls when they come in to audition,” she said. “Getting the first golden ticket, having somebody say, ‘You are going Hollywood. We believe in you.’ It was like, wow. It was validation.” 

Although she is new to the judges’ panel, the Oklahoma native admits she’s loving every minute of this new gig. 

“[It’s] so much fun to be on the other side of the desk and be the one that’s giving people that opportunity,” she shared with a big smile. 

Carrie Underwood; Photo by Disney/Eric McCandless
Carrie Underwood; Photo by Disney/Eric McCandless

During the latest episode of Idol, Underwood also reunited with the PS22 Kids; Chorus where she joined them in singing her 2007 hit, “So Small.” This emotional moment nearly brought Underwood to tears. Click below to watch. 

YouTube video

Throughout this milestone season of American Idol, Underwood is looking back on her Idol journey through a new series dubbed “Idol To Icon.” Premiering on YouTube, the series will find her reflecting on her American Idol season while guiding the new contestants as a judge.

Share on:

Lauren Jo Black

Written by

Lauren Jo Black

Lauren Jo Black is a longtime country music journalist, editor, host, and media personality whose work has helped shape the conversation around country music for nearly two decades. As the current Editor-in-Chief of Country Now, she has become one of the genre’s most respected voices, interviewing hundreds of country music’s biggest stars, including Dolly Parton, Garth Brooks, Reba McEntire, Shania Twain, Randy Travis, Luke Bryan, Carrie Underwood, Blake Shelton, Luke Combs, and countless others. Over the course of her career, Black’s written work and interviews have reached billions of country music fans worldwide. A 2009 graduate of the University of Central Florida, Black began her career by founding Country Music Is Love, one of country music’s earliest independent digital publications, which she later sold to a major record label in 2015 before it was rebranded as Sounds Like Nashville. She then served as the publication’s Editor-in-Chief for more than two years. Her work has also appeared in Forbes, and she previously served as the Country Music Expert for Answers.com. Widely recognized for her expertise, Black has appeared as a featured guest on The Bobby Bones Show, BobbyCast, and Scripps News Morning Rush, providing insight on country music’s biggest moments. She has also hosted Country Now Live, a concert series featuring performances from artists including Lady A, Dierks Bentley, Riley Green, Jordan Davis, Dustin Lynch, Gabby Barrett, Brett Young, Jon Pardi, Kip Moore, Chris Young, and more. The series has welcomed thousands of fans in person while reaching millions more online. In addition, she hosted Connect With Country Now, a weekly interview series featuring conversations with rising country stars. Throughout her career, Black has earned a reputation for discovering and championing artists long before they become household names. She has covered Luke Bryan since the early days of his career, beginning when he was writing songs for other artists, including Billy Currington’s No. 1 hit “Good Directions,” before stepping into the spotlight with his debut single, “All My Friends Say” and eventually becoming one of biggest names in music. She also gave Megan Moroney her first opportunity to walk a major red carpet as Country Now’s official guest correspondent at the 2022 CMA Awards. An interview she conducted in 2018 for Forbes.com with Luke Combs that inspired his multi-week No. 1 hit, “Doin’ This.” She has also hosted stages at CMA Fest, moderated an industry panel at Country Radio Seminar, and helped lead important conversations about the evolving landscape of country music media. Beyond journalism, Black has also used her platform to support charitable causes and highlight organizations making an impact. Through Country Now Live, she has helped raise awareness and support for St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital, while also advocating for animal rescue through Country Now’s Pupdate series, spotlighting organizations including MuttNation Foundation, Wags & Walks, and Proverbs 12:10 Animal Rescue. Black has been recognized as one of Country Aircheck’s Women of Influence and received the 2012 Rising Star Award from the University of Central Florida. She is a longtime member of both the Country Music Association (CMA) and the Academy of Country Music (ACM). After nearly 20 years covering country music, Lauren Jo Black has spent her career telling the stories behind the artists, songs, and moments that have shaped the genre. Her first-ever book, Country Music Forever: An A-to-Z Celebration of Icons, Songs and Stories, brings that same passion and firsthand knowledge to the page, celebrating not only the legendary artists and timeless songs that have become the soundtrack to generations of fans, but also the places, traditions, and cultural moments that have made country music one of the most beloved genres around the world.