Hannah Harper Turns Criticism Into a ‘Redemption Moment’ on ‘American Idol’s’ Disney Night

Hannah Harper leveled up her performance and had her “redemption moment” on Monday evening as she returned to the American Idol stage for Disney Night.

The Season 24 contestant opened up to this week’s guest judge Jennifer Hudson about how her previous performance of Jo Dee Messina’s “Heads Carolina, Tails California” sparked criticism online with users claiming her performance level doesn’t match the talent of her voice. With that feedback in mind, Harper made a strong effort to go out of her comfort zone and add some choreography to her delivery.

“Two weeks ago, I had all this choreography planned for ‘Heads Carolina, Tails California’ and I went out there and I froze like a statue,” Harper admitted. “And then as soon as I got online, everyone’s like, ‘Her voice is okay, but she sucks at performing.’ And I was like, ‘Yes, she does. They’re not wrong.’ This week is my redemption moment.”

Luckily, Hudson was there to help ease Haper’s nerves. The pair of artists practiced a bit of light choreography that helped the singer feel more comfortable with moving around the stage as she sang “Almost There” from Princess and the Frog. Hudson gave her the idea to just imagine that she’s at home dancing around the house with her three boys.

“Bringing me back home is super helpful just because it reminds me that’s my comfort zone. Acting like I’m just singing to my babies and just carrying on and that will change everything for me,” Harper reflected.

She began the performance seated on a stool beside the piano, wearing a stunning pink silk gown with matching gloves and a hairstyle reminiscent of the 1920s era the film is set in. Harper fully stepped into the character behind the song, starting with a softer, more intimate delivery before gradually rising from her seat and moving across the stage.

As the performance built, she connected with the audience more and more, leaning into the moment and letting the energy of the song take over. By the final chorus, she was moving freely across the stage and delivered a final note to remember. Her powerful vocals once again stood out, earning a standing ovation from the judges, her fellow contestants, and the live audience.

Luke Bryan was first to speak from the judging panel, and without hesitation admitted he “loved” the performance, calling it “one of my favorite performances you’ve ever done.”

“It made my heart smile. It made me smile watching you grow into…You kind of started with this Reba McEntire attitude thing and then you grew into your character, and you didn’t overdo anything. You did it perfectly,” he praised.

Lionel Richie also commended her delivery but offered some helpful advice at the same time.  

“I learned this long time ago. What you do is…whatever shoes you’re going to wear on stage, make sure you wear them in rehearsal so that your shoes don’t scare you to death when you start moving. I saw you concentrating on ‘how much can I dare on that step?’ Otherwise, your performance was amazing.”

Next up was Carrie Underwood, who revealed that she related to Harper’s situation as she too was criticized during her Idol days for not being a very strong performer.

“This is another way that you remind me of myself because I got dragged when I was on this show for not moving enough. And honestly, it was just, I had never done anything like this before. And now I can’t not move. I can sing with my entire body,” she explained, giving the singer some hope that she will learn and grow with time.”

“So I feel like you are on your way. Just keep taking those steps. Keep getting more comfortable in the space that you’re in. You were in character. You sounded beautiful. You look gorgeous. You should be very proud,” Underwood added.

Hudson agreed with her fellow judges and congratulated Harper on all the progress she made, even just from their time together backstage to the full-blown performance.  

“Everything they just said and more, you look absolutely beautiful, first of all. And I love how you were natural and true to yourself in this moment. And I know that’s not your cup of tea to be able to perform and sing, but you stood there and you sang this song and you gave us a little bit here and there. You’re on your way,” she told Harper.

Hannah Harper’s performance earned her enough of American’s votes to move forward in the Top 7. She is joined by Daniel Stallworth, Keyla Richardson, Jordan McCullough, Chris Tungseth, Brooks Rosser, and Braden Rumfelt.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by American Idol (@americanidol)

Next week on American Idol the remaining contestants will take part in “Taylor Swift Night,” performing hits from the superstar’s catalog in hopes of securing a spot in the Top 5. Comedian and “Swiftie” Nikki Glaser will also join as a guest judge.

American Idol airs Mondays at 8/7c on ABC and Disney+ and steams the next day on Hulu.